Wu Qing, Zhang Jiren,
Department of Oncology, Jing'an Elder People Hospital, Shanghai
Oncology Center of PLA, Zhujiang Hospital, The First Military Medical
University, Guangzhou
(Abstract) Object: to eveluate effectiveness as
well as the syndrome by observing the patients treated by Endocare
cryosurgery system. Methods: by the means of CT and B ultra short
wave orientation and inducing, percutaneous Argon and Helium targeted
ablation for treatment of liver cancer, using Crycare surgery system.
Results: the patients are in good conditions during and after the
operation, can recover soon, have no bleeding as well as the gallbladder
will not be hurt or damaged. After the operation, 85% of the patients
get fever and the low fever continue 2-7 day. The change of liver
chemical enzyme is 81%(36 cases among 44) as well as the occurrence
rate of the reactive thorax hydrocele is 20.4% (9 cases among 44).
Among the 9 hydrocele cases, two have two-side thorax hydrocele,
one has an abscess below the diaphragm, which has been cured by
drainage. The occurrence rate of the lag reactive alimentary canal
bleeding is 5.4% (two cases among 44) and among the two cases, one
is dead ; therefore the mortality of the operation is 2.2% (one
case among 44) . After the operation, based-on the follow-up whose
duration is between 5 and 18 months, 15 cases are dead and the survival
rate after one year is 65.9% as well as the one-year survival rate
of the entire refrigeration patients is 90% ( 9 cases among 10).
Conclusion: percutaneous Ar-He targeted ablation therapy is feasible,
safety, effective with less syndrome and less hurt; however, the
rudimental rate of the cancer is relatively high, which needs further
improvement.
Key Words: Liver Cancer, Percutaneous targeted ablation
Therapy
The incidence rate of liver cancer is relatively
high in China; however, the operation-cutting rate is comparatively
low as well as the recrudescent rate is high. Therefore, the comprehensive
curative effect is not satisfactory. In recent tow years, foreign
countries adopts the new argon and helium superconductor cryocare
surgical system (in short form: Argon and Helium Scalpel) that punctures
through the liver skin and directly refrigerates the cancer, and
has made significant effectiveness. Zhang Jiren, Wang Senming and
other people have successfully conducted this methods to cure liver
cancer via B ultra short wave inducing(1). During the period between
January 2000 and February of 2001, our hospital, adopting CT orientation
and B ultra shot wave inducing, treated liver cancer 44 cases by
percutaneous Ar-He targeted cryoablation therapy. The details are
reported as the following.
1. The clinic data
1.1 General information: 44 patients with liver
cancer, were treated by percutaneous Ar-He targeted cryoablation
therapy, including 27 male cases; 17 female cases. The oldest one
is 72 years old, the youngest is 34 as well as the average age is
59.2 years old. Among the 44 cases, there are original liver cancer
32 cases and transferring liver cancer 12 cases. The 44 cases totally
accepted refrigeration 51 times, among which, 3 cases were frozen
in the process of ventrotomy and 41 cases were treated through oriented
refrigeration, including three cases of being frozen twice as well
as two cases of being frozen three times. The biggest size of the
cancer is 12×10× 9cm3 and the smallest is 3.4×2.6×3.6cm3. Among
the cases, 11 cases' cancer entangles together with the liver cover
film, two cases' pylori veins are embolized by cancer, four cases
have slight liver ascites, 38 cases' liver function level is Child
A as well as 6 cases' liver function level is B. The phases of the
cancer: Ib phase: one case, IIa phase 16 cases, IIb phase 12 cases
as well as IIIa phase 3 cases. During the operation, 3 cases only
used one incision, 23 cases used 2 incisions, 14 cases used three
incisions as well as 11 cases used four incisions.
1.2 Applicable Field of the Treatment: Original
liver cancer with the diameter ≤12cm or the volume of the cancer
occupies less than 50% of the liver's volume; the number of the
focuses of the original cancer is ≤3个, the number of the focuses
of the transferred cancer should be more than 4 or 5, in addition,
the focuses of the original cancer should been cut already; the
patients who have light or middle level hepatocirrhosis and the
liver function level is Child A or B;the patients with original
liver cancer which has transferred out of the liver; however, the
cancer has been cut through operation or refrigeration; huge cancer,
which has harmed the celiac veins, also can be treated by refrigeration;
if the pylori veins are embolized by cancer, the refrigeration should
be conducted together with the "liver artery & pylori vein
bio-pumping operation" to avoid the validity of the simple
refrigeration.
1.3 The taboo, namely the cases who are suitable
for the treatment: Patients with significant icterus or ascites,
which can not be alleviated by treatment; the patients whose liver
function level is Child C;the patients who have serious hepatocirrhosis
and high blood pressure of pylori veins; the cancer's volume has
excess 60% of the liver's entire volume or the caner has extensively
transferred; the patients whose cruor functions are abnormal or
who have bleeding tendencies.
1.4 The designing and orientation of the refrigeration:
the authors of this article adopt CT orientation method to judge
the size, shape, location, circumstance of the cancer via the three-dimension
image demonstrated by CT. After overall comparison and measuring,
the site, layer, type of the "cold scalpel", angle, depth
will be decided. Then, the puncture spots will be marked one by
one (please refer to diagram 1). All the refrigeration is conducted
after abdomen has been opened by operation and B ultra short wave
shall play the roles of exploring direction and inducing.
1.5 The procedures of the operation
Local anesthesia with 0.5% Lidocaine or allo-propyl-hydroxybenene
2mg/kg. Referring to the three-dimension image, under the inducing
of B ultra short wave, the doctors adopt Sholder technique to puncture
the site and conduct the refrigeration. The cycle of refrigeration-
temperature restoring-refrigeration will be repeated twice. In each
time, the refrigeration period should last 15 minutes. If the cancer
is significantly large, two more cycles can be adopted with withdrawing
the cryoprob 3-3.5 cm till the cancer is totally frozen and decomposed.
After withdrawing the cryoprob, the specialized bleeding stanching
bolt should be used immediately in case the bleeding will happen.
If necessary, the protein blood coagulant should be injected. Basically,
no stitch is needed after operation.
2 The Result of the Operation:
During and after the operation, the patients are in good conditions,
can recover very soon, can eat food immediately and can walk on
the next day. There are no liver film cracking cases, no gallbladder
leaking cases and no transplanting transferring cases. After the
refrigeration, AFP of 43.4% of the patients recover to the normal
level (14 among the 32 cases), and AFP level of 16 patients has
got significant dropping (16 cases among 32). Only 0.62% of the
patients have not got any changes in the term of AFP (2 cases among
32). 85% of the cases get fever after the operations, which lasts
2 to 7 days; the liver function change was found to be 81% (36 cases
among 44), which lasts approximately one week; the occurrence rate
of the reactive thorax hydrocele is 20.4% (9 cases among 44), among
which two have two-side thorax hydrocele as well as one has an abscess
below the diaphragm, which has been cured by drainage.The occurrence
rate of the lag reactive alimentary canal bleeding is 5.4% (two
cases among 44) and among the two cases, one is dead ; therefore
the mortality of the operation is 2.2% (one case among 44). 10 cases
are entire refrigeration ones and two of them are huge cancers,
which are refrigerated three times and the cancers are eliminated
eventually. 19 cases' refrigeration area surpasses 85% if the tatol
area, 13 cases surpass 75% of the total area, as well only 2 cases'
refrigeration area is less than 60% of the total. Based-on the follow-up
whose duration is between 5 and 18 months, 15 cases are dead and
the survival rate after one year is 65.9% as well as the one-year
survival rate of the entire refrigeration patients is 90% ( 9 cases
among 10).
3.Conlusion:
Percutaneous targeted cryoablation therapy for treatment of liver
cancer is feasible, safety, effective with less syndrome and less
liver hurt. Combining with chemotherapy and radiotherapy, It will
promot the progress of clinical oncology.
4.Discusstion
The effectiveness of the treatment is closely related
to the operation designing, orientation and the inducing methods.
Currently, there is not itself three-dimension designing system
available. Therefore, the designing and the orientation more depend
on CT or B ultrasound scan the personal experiences and ability,
which leads to the differences. The weakness of the designing, the
inaccuracy of the orientation will lower the effectiveness of the
operation directly. Therefore, different methods should be adopted
according to different actual situations. The authors' experiences
are presented as the following: the designing based on CT two dimension
diagram will be more accurate than the B ultra short wave based
ones. Even some operations can be induced by CT to improve the effectiveness
and to reduce the syndrome. Currently, the negative effect of the
patient's respirations on the operation can not overcome well yet;
however, patient can hold his breath temporarily to solve the problem.
Some patients who easily get refrigeration syndrome or are not suitable
for accepting the operation through the "orientation refrigeration"
can be treated by B ultra inducing refrigeration during the process
of celiotomy operation.
The syndrome and its effects: The serious one is the massive haemorrhage
and the lag reactive alimentary bleeding, which possibly cause death.
Especially the lag reactive alimentary bleeding, its cause has not
been clearly, may be connection with the satuation of patient, such
as serious hepatocirrhosis, pylori veins high blood pressure, the
decrease of the liver's storage ability as well as the too large
scale of frozen range for huge cancers. The common symptom is: bleeding
is found in two weeks after the operation, the exhaustion of the
liver functions, icterus as well as massive ascites. According to
the report of Fred T.Lee(5), the occurrence rate of the lag reactive
alimentary bleeding is 1%; in our cases, the occurrence rate is
4.5% (2 cases among 44). The two cases are both suffered from the
serious hepatocirrhosis and the sizes of their cancers are 9-10cm.
The cases both happened at the begging stage of our research. Later,
since huge cancers are refrigerated by several times and the patients
with serious hepatocirrhosis pylori veins high blood pressure are
not allowed to be treated by this kind of operation, the lag reactive
alimentary bleeding never occurs. The massive haemorrhage has not
happened in our researched cases. However, the authors believe the
massive haemorrhage has the connection with piercing the blood vessel
in the process of puncturing, which can be averted by adopting the
puncturing directions. cryoprob direct insert on the artery may
cause the massive hemorrhage; therefore, it will be avoided in operation.
The above syndrome will put negative effects on the refrigeration's
effectiveness. The feverl is relation with the range of refrigeration.it
is only the normal reaction.
The evaluation of the effectiveness: Currently, it is hard to evaluate
the long period effectiveness. Different data groups indicate the
different TNM stages and syndrome of the cases. The distinctions
between the one-year survival rates in different groups are various.
In our cases, the one-year survival rate of the entire frozen cases
is much higher than it of the rudimental cancer cases. Two years
after the operation, the health conditions of the two groups are
significantly different. If the cancer rudimental rate is less than
15%, the improvement of the patient's health condition is significant
with the weight increase and AFP declining. If the cancer rudimental
rate is more than 65%, the improvement of the patient's health condition
is hard to be identified.
Based on the clinical observation, the authors propose our own opinion:
the refrigeration can be divided into two categories: eradicative
refrigeration and appeasement refrigeration. Eradicative refrigeration
refers to the cases whose refrigeration range exceeds the brim the
cancer more than 1 cm, without cancer transferring and without rudimental
cancer. Appeasement refrigeration refers to the cases with rudimental
cancer. The refrigeration range of the appeasement treatment should
exceed 85% of the cancer's volume; otherwise the effectiveness will
not be significant. In addition, to select the reasonable comprehensive
treatment scheme also contributes to the effectiveness of the refrigeration.
Emphasis should be put on the comprehensiveness of the treatment.
According the authors' experiences, combining withchemotherapy may
helpful for elevating the survival rate as well as reducing the
recurring or transferring after cryotherapy.
REFERENCES
1.Wang Xuehao ,The Treatment Selection of the Middle or Late Stage
Liver Cancers in Surgery Theories and Practice 2000 Volume 5
2.Yang Jiahai, Chen Han and Wu Mengchao The Resecting of the Huge
Liver Cancers (attached by 86 cases) in Practical Surgery Magazine
1999,19
3.Senming Wang,Jiren,Zhang,The treament of irresectable liver tumors
by percutaneous targeted Ar-He crgoablation International journal
of Modern Cancer Therapy Vol,3No.1(2000)pp16~18
4.Deng Xiaojun Using the "Argon and Helium Scalpel" Ultra
Low Temperature Combined with Liver Artery & Pylori Veins
Pumping Operation to Treat Liver Cancer Combined with Pylori Vein
Cancer Embolism in China General Surgery Magazine,2001. Volume
10, Page 179 to 181
5.Fred T.Lee,Jr,et al Hepatic Cryosurgery with Interacperativ US
Guidance.Scanlan Radiology,Vol.202,No.3 pp624~632 March,1997
(Manuscrpt was accepted at July, 2001)
|