Zhang jiren
Inetrnational Journal of Modern Cancer Therapy.2002
(in press)
Oncology Center of PLA, Zhujiang Hospital, Guangzhou, China
How to destroy the tumor tissue quickly and release the patients
with cancer from tumor inhibition and painful situation? How to
increase the life span of cancer patient using a therapy with feasible,
effective, less hurt and less side effect? With the development
of Cryocare surgery system, a new targeted ablation therapy has
been successfully used to treat lung, liver, breast, brain, and
prostate tumors recent years(1-2). About 1500 cases of cancer patients
have received this new targeted therapy from October 1999 to March
2002 in China according to the account of China Collaboration Group
for Argon-Helium Targeted Cryoablation Therapy(1, 3-9). The quality
of life was improved obviously in all the treated patients and the
short-term effect was prominent following up by collaboration group
doctors. The applications of Cryocare surgery system has promoted
the development of tumor targeted therapy and clinical oncology
progress.
Cryocare surgery system : A new technology for tumor micro-wound
surgery
Cryosurgery System is manufactured by American Endocare Corporation.
Using insert-type cryoprobes, it can form an iceball of 3cm to 8cm
in diameter to destroy the target tissue and induce necrosis and
apoptosis of tumor cells. With these insert-type cryoprobes, cancer
surgeon can take targeted ablation tumor tissue with a higher resection
rate, and isovolumetric resection tumor tissue without tumor cell
transferation during operation. Using targeted cryoablation tumor
tissue can modulate anti-tumor immunological response, suggesting
a new concept of immunological surgery. Targeted ablation therapy
with Cryocare surgery system provide a new technology for tumor
micro-wound surgery.
While radical resection remains the first systemic treatment modality
for tumor at present, the best chance of radical operation in 60~70%
or more cancer patients has been missed when diagnosed. The most
commonly causes included: regular operation of the heavy tumor burden
influences normal organ function; poor performance status; heart
or lung dysfunction of patient can not tolerate any big operation
(such as thoracotomy, laparotomy). The micro-wound physical therapy
intention of completely destroy the tumor cells and eliminate the
tumor burden, had provided a new method for cancer patients. Ar-He
targeted cryosurgery system has the advantage of little wound, quick
remission, and little influence on vital organs. Cryosurgery procedure
can be operated under the guidance of B-type ultrasonography, celioscope,
thorascope. Percutaneous targeted cryosurgery can also be done under
the guidance of B-type ultrasonography, CT, MR, simulation X-ray
localizer and x-ray. Most solid tumor ranged from 5cm to 10cm can
be treated with targeted ablation therapy to destroy the tumor through
endocare surgery system. The formed ice-ball is 1cm to 1.5cm exceed
the border as image showed. For those primary cancer patients without
extensive metastasis and local metastatic patients, and can't tolerate
regular operation or reject to be operated, Ar-He targeted cryosurgery
is a perfect choice. Cryosurgery need not remove the frozen tumor
tissue. The advantages include easy manipulation, little complications
and quickly clinical effect.
Palliative cryoablation can enhance the effects of systemic therapy
A. lower dosage of chemotherapy.
B. lower dosage of radiotherapy.
C. lessen side effects and improve quality of life.
Indications of targeted ablation therapy are enumerated as follows.
Tumors located near big vessels, bile duct, trachea, nerve or vital
organ are difficult to be radical resected and radical cryosurgery.
Huge tumor complicated light organ function decompensation can't
tolerate great operation and cryosurgery. Palliative cryosurgery
is the indication for those intention of just lessening tumor volume
or load. Cryosurgery once or multiple times for tumor body can achieve
part remission, lighten tumor depletion, lessening pain, and improvement
of quality of life. Systemic therapy after cryosurgery looks more
important for those residual focus, subclinical focus difficulty
to be found by image examinations. Clinical studies reveals that
drug injection (such as low content acetic acid and sodium hydroxide,
high osmotic saline, alcohol, chemotherapeutical drugs) at residual
focus will enhance the effects of cryoablation. Some doctors suggest
that palliative cryosurgery will decrease the dosage, shorten the
time limit, and reduce their complications of radiotherapy and chemotherapy.
The attitude in treating multi- focus either primary or metastatic
are different. The majority literate believe that do our best to
lighten tumor load if patient can tolerate, is benefit to reinforce
the curative effects of systemic treatment. Treating with subclinical
focus and latent residual tumor cells, palliative cryosurgery must
combinate with other systemic therapy.
Further study is needed on how to improve the clinical effects of
chemotherapy and radiotherapy with the help of local cryoabalation.
How to prevent local relapse and distant metastasis is still a keystone
in clinical oncology.
Conformal plan and accurate localization, key step of radical cryoablation
Destroying the tumor rapidly and accurately is the characterization
of Ar-He targeted ablation therapy obviously. Without reference
to the tumor size and shape, single or multi- time treatment, the
formed ice-ball must cover the whole tumor. Most doctors believed
the ice-ball encroach 1cm over run the tumor in image might guarantee
inactivating tumor tissue completely. To reduce the residual of
tumor cells in a great extent is a key step in preventing local
relapse and improving curative effects. Conformal cryosurgery can
be done during surgery operation under the guidance of B-type ultrasonography
or CT in multi- dimensions and angles. In percutaneous cryoablation,
curative effects are correlated with monitoring condition and doctors'
proficiency, experience, but conformal plan and accuracy localization
are most crucial. So it is very important to utilize temperature
assay probes exactly, master image diagnosis and have skillful monitoring
experience.
Curative effect evaluation and clinical research expectation
Ar-He targeted cryoablation is a local physical technology of destroying
tumor tissue directly. The curative effect evaluation of short term
mainly depends on the tumor volume decrease, symptoms improvement
and laboratory index variation. The difference between Ar-He cryosurgery
and regular operation is the former doesn't remove the inactivating
tumor tissue by freezing. The great difference between regular radiotherapy
and chemotherapy and cryosurgery is the latter can destroy tumor
cells rapidly, but the absorption of the cryogenic necrotic tissues
is a slow process. Therefore, judge the curative effects from the
changes of tumor size and shape is incomprehensive. The curative
effects are judged from the changes of the size of iceball and tumor,
CT value and blood vessel density in the target area pre- &
post- operation(3-8). 1. Clinical complete remission: for cryosurgery
ablation therapy patients, the iceball is 1cm to 1.5cm or more beyond
the tumor border, postoperative CT or MRI examination registers
the disappear of tumor; or the tumor shrinkage prominently post-operation,
image confirmation the tumor become into inactivating tissue and
lost its multiplication ability with lower density, no or little
blood vessel, low CT value or MR signal; no new focus appear maintenance
for more than one month, clinical symptoms disappear, body weight
increases, tumor marker lower to normal level, quality of life improved
prominently or bring back to normal. 2. Clinical partial remission:
Palliative targeted ablation therapy patients, the freezing area
occupying more than 50% in total volume, CT or MR reveals the disappear
of the frozen tumor; or shrinkage obviously. The residual tumor
stop growing, no new lesion appears for more than one month, clinical
symptoms improved, tumor marker lowered distinctly, quality of life
improved prominently. 3. No change. palliative targeted ablation
therapy patients, the freezing area occupying less than 50% in total
volume, CT or MR reveals the disappear of the frozen tumor; or shrinkage
obviously. The residual tumor grow less than 25% in volume, no new
lesion appear, clinical symptoms and quality of life without prominent
improvement, tumor marker lower little. 4. Progression. Part palliative
targeted ablation therapy patients, the freezing volume shrinkage
little, and CT or MR showes new proliferative property. The residual
tumor grow more than 25% in volume, and with new lesion appear,
clinical symptoms progress and quality of life keep down.
Curative effects evaluation in the long future rely on the analysis
of materials acquired from follow-up study about local relapse rate,
distant metastasis rate, mean survival time, median survival time,
survival rate, quality of life. Ar-He cryosurgery system is a product
of the development of low temperature medicine. It is a physical
therapeutical method that can destroy tumor rapidly like operation.
With widely developing of targeted cryoablation therapy in clinical
oncology, the project and period of treatment of traditional radiotherapy
and chemotherapy would be changed. How to understand and evaluate
the significance of targeted cryoablation therapy in clinical oncology
practice? How to design the assistant radiotherapy and chemotherapy
plan after targeted cryoablation therapy? How to combine cryosurgery
together with systemic therapy reasonablly? How to comprehend cryosurgery
modulates cell immunology and its molecular biological mechanism?
How to design the best targeted cryosurgery plan and disciplines
for every kind of cancer? How about the regularity of tumor-related
biological marker changing and its significance after cryosurgery?
All the questions mentioned above are the topics of collaboration
group in the future. These achievements of clinical studies will
greatly accelerate the development of low temperature medicine,
and promote the development of tumor therapy and clinical oncology
progress. Some basic principles like randomization, contrast, repeat
and balance must be followed in designing clinical trial.
References
1. Senming Wang, Jiren Zhang et al . The Treatment of Irresectable
liver Tumors by percutaneous Targeted Ar-He Cryoablation. Inetrnational
Journal of Modern Cancer Therapy.2000;3(1):16-18
2. Fred T.Lee,Jr,David M.Mahvi et al.Hepatic Cryosurgery withintraoperative
US Guidance.Scanlan Radiology,Vol.202,No.3 PP624-632,march,1997
3. Zhangjiren, et al. Ar-He Targeted ablation Technology 2002 (in
publication)
4. Wu Qing, Zhang Jiren, Clinical eveluation on Argon-Helium Targeted
ablation Therapy for Treatment of Liver Cancer. Inetrnational Journal
of Modern Cancer Therapy.2002(in press)
5. Wu Qing, Wu Xueyong , Feng Jianping The Clinical Application
of Cryocare Surgery System in the Treatment for Rear Peritoneum
Leiomyoma's Recurrence After Operation. Inetrnational Journal of
Modern Cancer Therapy.2002 (in press)
6. An Yonghui,Zhang Futong,Li Xiuli The Clinical Observation of
the Patients with Non-Small cell Lung Cancer Treated by Percutaneous
Argon-Helium Targeted Ablation. Inetrnational Journal of Modern
Cancer Therapy.2002 (in press)
7. Song huazhi Yi fengtao Zhang yuxing Treatment of Liver Tumors
by Targeted Ar-He Cryoablation. Inetrnational Journal of Modern
Cancer Therapy.2002 (in press)
8. Wu Qing, Wu Xueyong, Feng Jianping , Zhang Jiren, The Clinical
Analysis on 30 cases of Patients with Non-Small cell Lung Cancer
Treated by Percutaneous Targeted Cryoablation Therapy. Inetrnational
Journal of Modern Cancer Therapy.2002 ( in press)
9. Zhang Zongcheng, Jiang Jianxiao, Li Kaibin. Targeted-Cryoablation
for Solid Tumor: A Clinical Analysis of 41 Cases. Inetrnational
Journal of Modern Cancer Therapy.2002 ( in press)
|